What Actually Triggers a Buy-Sell Agreement in an LLC: Death, Divorce, Default, and Deadlock

Four upright domino tiles in a row, the first tipping toward the second.

Four events do most of the work: an owner dies, an owner divorces, an owner's creditor comes after the units, or the owners stop agreeing on anything. A buy-sell agreement in an LLC is the set of instructions for what happens on each of those days, and in Texas the instructions carry more weight than owners expect, because the statute supplies no exit of its own. Tex. Bus. Orgs. Code § 101.107 reads: "A member of a limited liability company may not withdraw or be expelled from the company."

Texas law supplies no exit, so the triggers have to be written

Section 101.107 is one sentence long and it closes both doors at once. A member cannot leave on their own, and the other members cannot remove them. Whatever exit exists in a Texas LLC exists because somebody wrote it into the company agreement.

The Code hands that job to the agreement expressly. Section 101.052 provides that the company agreement governs the relations among members, managers, officers, assignees and the company itself, and that a provision of the title may be waived or modified in the agreement except as § 101.054 provides. Section 101.054 lists the provisions that cannot be waived, and § 101.107 is not on the list. Under § 101.1115(b), the chapter does not impair an agreement for the purchase or sale of a membership interest at any time, including on the death or divorce of an owner.

The Code also says what happens when an agreement does grant a way out. Under § 101.205, a member who validly exercises a right to withdraw granted under the company agreement is entitled to the fair value of the interest, determined as of the date of withdrawal and paid within a reasonable time. Our view: an agreement that grants an exit should set its own price and payment terms rather than rest on "fair value" and "a reasonable time" alone.

So the question is not whether you are allowed to write triggers. It is which days you wrote instructions for. If your company agreement is silent, the four sections below describe what happens instead, and none of them produces a buyout. For the wider case on why these documents earn their keep, see does an LLC need an operating agreement in Texas.

Death turns an owner's family into assignees, not members

On a member's death, § 101.1115(a)(2) makes the surviving spouse, if any, and any heir, devisee, personal representative or other successor an assignee of the membership interest, to the extent of their respective interest. Assignee is a narrower status than it sounds.

Section 101.108(b) provides that an assignment does not entitle the assignee to participate in the management and affairs of the company, to become a member, or to exercise any rights of a member. Section 101.109(a) gives the assignee the allocations of income, gain, loss, deduction and credit and the distributions that were assigned, along with the right to examine company records described in § 101.502. Section 101.109(b) provides that an assignee is entitled to become a member on the approval of all of the company's members.

Read together, the shape is clear. The estate inherits the tax consequences of the interest, a look at the company's records and the right to whatever distributions the company declares, but not a vote on whether the company declares any. Under § 101.204, even a member may not demand a distribution until the company's governing authority declares one. In a company managed by its members, that authority is the members (§ 101.251), which here means the surviving owners.

Divorce puts a former spouse in exactly the same position

Section 101.1115(a)(1) provides that on the divorce of a member, the member's spouse is an assignee of the membership interest, to the extent of the spouse's membership interest, if any. Section 101.1115(a)(3) does the same where it is the member's spouse who dies and the interest passes to that spouse's successors.

The practical result is a person with an economic stake in the company, no management rights, and every reason to want liquidity the company has no obligation to provide. A trigger provision is what converts that standing arrangement into a purchase. Whether an interest can even move in the first place is a separate question, covered in transfer restrictions in LLC and partnership agreements.

Default brings in a judgment creditor, and a charging order is all they get

When an owner's personal debt ends in a judgment, the creditor's route to the interest runs through § 101.112. On application by a judgment creditor, a court may charge the membership interest to satisfy the judgment. The creditor then has only the right to receive any distribution the debtor would otherwise have received on that interest.

The charging order is a lien that may not be foreclosed on under the Code or any other law, and entry of the order is the exclusive remedy by which a judgment creditor may satisfy a judgment out of the interest. The section adds that a creditor of a member has no right to obtain possession of the company's property or to exercise remedies against it, and that it applies to single-member and multiple-member companies alike.

That is protective of the business and awkward for everyone in it. The creditor cannot take the company, but they can sit in the distribution line for as long as the judgment lasts, watching the owners decide what to distribute. A creditor-event trigger gives the company a way to buy the interest out instead of living beside it.

Deadlock's statutory remedies end the company or bring in a receiver, and neither is a buyout

When owners simply stop agreeing, the Code offers two routes, and both run through a court. The first is in § 11.314. A district court in the county of the entity's registered office or principal place of business in Texas has jurisdiction to order the winding up and termination of a domestic partnership or limited liability company on the application of an owner, if the court determines that the economic purpose of the entity is likely to be unreasonably frustrated, that another owner has engaged in conduct relating to the entity's business that makes it not reasonably practicable to carry on the business with that owner, or that it is not reasonably practicable to carry on the entity's business in conformity with its governing documents.

The second is a receiver. Under § 11.404(a)(1)(B), a court may appoint one in an action by an owner if the governing persons are deadlocked in the management of the entity's affairs, the owners cannot break the deadlock, and irreparable injury to the entity is being suffered or is threatened because of it. Subsection (b) adds conditions, among them that the court determines all other available legal and equitable remedies are inadequate. Subsection (c) ends the receivership once the condition is remedied.

Notice what those remedies do. One winds the company up. The other puts its property and business in a receiver's hands. Neither prices one owner out and leaves the business running with the other. A deadlock-breaking provision in the company agreement — a shotgun clause, a put right at a formula price, an appraisal process — is an attempt to keep the going concern alive while one owner leaves. Sections 11.314 and 11.404 are what remain when nobody wrote one.

A worked example of a buy-sell agreement in an LLC on the day an owner dies

The following scenario is hypothetical and constructed to show the mechanics. It is not a real matter.

Three people own a Texas LLC in equal one-third shares and manage it themselves. The company has made no election about its tax classification, so it is taxed as a partnership, which is the default for a domestic LLC with at least two members. The company agreement covers management and distributions but says nothing about death. One owner dies in March.

The estate becomes an assignee under § 101.1115(a)(2). The following year the company earns $900,000 of taxable income, and the estate's one-third share, $300,000, is reported to it on a Schedule K-1. The two surviving owners, who hold the votes, declare $120,000 of total distributions, of which the estate receives $40,000.

A partner takes its share of partnership income into account "whether or not distributed" under section 1.702-1(a) of the Treasury regulations, and under section 1.736-1(a)(1)(ii) a deceased partner's successor is treated as a partner until its interest is completely liquidated. So the estate has $300,000 of income to report and $40,000 in hand. It cannot demand a larger distribution, and it cannot become a member without the approval of all members under § 101.109(b), meaning the two people on the other side of the conversation.

Now change one thing. The company agreement says death is a purchase event; the company must give notice within 60 days; the price is the formula the owners agreed in advance; and payment is 20 percent at closing with the balance over 48 months at a stated rate, funded by a company-owned life policy. On the same facts, the estate is paid, the survivors keep control, and nobody is allocated income on an interest they cannot turn into cash. The difference between the two versions is a few paragraphs written years earlier, on a day when nobody was angry. The mechanics of documenting that purchase are covered in redemption agreements in LLC and partnership exits.

What to read in your own company agreement

Pull the document and look for four things: whether death is named as an event, whether divorce is, whether a creditor action or personal bankruptcy is, and whether there is any mechanism at all for an owner who wants out when the others do not. Then look at how price is determined, and at whether the money has a source — a funded policy, a sinking fund, a note with real terms — rather than a formula and a hope.

Circumstances differ, and a provision that works for a three-owner company with one line of business can fail for the same company after it adds investors or a second entity. If you want a read on what your own agreement does on those four days, our business and corporate practice is a reasonable place to start the conversation.

Disclaimer. This publication is provided by Amini & Conant, LLP for educational and informational purposes only and is not intended and should not be construed as legal advice. Should the reader seek further analysis of the subject matter or answers to specific questions about the subject matter, please contact the author at neema@aminiconant.com. This publication is considered advertising under applicable state laws.

Endnotes

Let's Talk